The latter is the view defended by david lewis who claims that possible worlds. A possible world where, say, david lewis became a fisherman instead of a philosopher, is a concrete reality, just as actual as our world to those who inhabit it. I note two competing ambitions for a theory of possible worlds. David lewis possible worlds free download as pdf file. December 1996 elusive knowledge david lewis we know a lot. Lewis calls these universes \ worlds, deliberately recalling the notion of a \ possible world familiar from modal logic and the metaphysics of modality. Reassessing the forrestarmstrong argument 20112018 phillip bricker university of massachusetts amherst 1. If you want to know whats historically possible, just take every world with the same history as ours right up to whenever you have the. An argument against david lewis theory of possible worlds. The paradoxes of time travel are oddities, not impossibilities.
Watch part 1 of our discussion on david lewis modal realism to find out. Following this, lewis considers content of possible worlds and. The possible worlds dont all agree on the truth of these sentences. Possible worlds in the context of literary theory 16 3. Through the questions they ask, pwinspired approaches have.
Pdf the expressive power of the possible worlds theory. Inhistwo concepts of possible worlds 1986, peter van inwagen explores and opposes two kinds of views about the nature of possible worlds. Scribd is the worlds largest social reading and publishing site. In this article, i discuss the view, championed by david lewis, that philosophers talk of possible worlds is the literal truth. David lewiss possible worlds theory of fiction tested. The views principal proponent is david lewis, and his label for. Reproduced from david lewis, papers in metaphysics and epistemology cambridge. If you havent smelled a skunk, then you dont know what its. Haecceitism, antihaecceitism, and possible worlds bradford skow abstract possible worlds talk obscures, rather than clari. If a sentence sis true according to a possible world w i. The american philosopher david lewis 1941 2001 argued that, beyond this world, the actual world, there are countless possible worlds of a certain nature. Together they constitute a doctrine which i will call extreme realism about possible worlds. This paper sets out and evaluates a leading contemporary theory of possible worlds, david lewis s modal realism.
Possible worlds are required to account for the facts of modality without assuming that. Other possible worlds are just as real as the actual world. He made significant contributions to philosophy of language, philosophy of mathematics, philosophy of science, decision theory, epistemology, metaethics and aesthetics. They prove only this much, which few would have doubted. One position on these matters is set forth in david lewis. The core idea is that if we take possible worlds as basic ontological entities, then we can use them to give a reductive account of many other things such as propositions, properties, and modal concepts. Matt teichman from the elucidations podcast joins mark, wes, and dylan to figure out what this might mean. The originator and, by far, the best known proponent of concretism is david lewis.
If you want to know whats physically possible, just take every world where physics is the same as ours. Yet counterexamples have emerged, which suggest a need to invoke causal. David lewis famously holds that reality consists not only of our own universe, but also of countless other universes as real as our own. David lewis on possible worlds and language games part two april. The concept of possible worlds in literary theory 21 3. Counterfactuals, causal independence and conceptual. The author of the paper rejects modal realism, and wishes to discredit it by showing that it entails a bizarre conclusion, or perhaps just make light of it. Lewis also considers the idea of closeness of possible worlds and defines such notions as counterfactuals and verisimilitude. Three philosophical conceptions of possible worlds. David lewis 19412001 was one of the most important philosophers of the 20th century.
To say that something here in our actual world is such that it might have done soandso is not to say that there is a possible world in which that thing itself. Hence, unpacked in terms of the abstractionists definitions, the possible world truth conditions for modal. Possible worlds the concept of possible worlds henceforth pw, loosely inspired by leibniz. Lewis gives many examples of the parameters by which the context the score may shift, and for instance, we have another go at austins performatives as described in ep. David lewis s semantics for counterfactuals remains the standard view. The first statement seems to read, in every possible world in every possible world a, and the second, in every possible world in some world a. Forrest and armstrong, in an argument against david lewis theory. David lewis, as well as by a number of literary theorists, including eco, pavel, dolezel, and ryan. In this paper i distinguish haecceitism and antihaecceitism from.
Convention i a philosophical study david lewis biackweli publishers. Possible worlds david lewis thinking about thinking. We will try to show the pragmatic character of lewis arguments in support of this metaphysics of possible worlds. Im trying to learn modal logic and im having trouble translating sentences like a and a into natural language using possible world semantics. To argue this point i will state four theses about possible worlds, all defended by lewis. Counterfactuals university of california, berkeley. Ive just been reading about david lewis modal realism in louxs introductory textbook metaphysics. They disagree, however, over its proper interpretation. Hence, unpacked in terms of the abstractionists definitions, the possible world truth conditions for modal propositions are themselves irreducibly modal. Lewis indexical argument for worldrelative actuality. These possible worlds exist and are as real as the actual one.
Philosophers agree, for the most part, that possible worlds talk is extremely useful for explicating concepts and formulating theories. Modality, for lewis and lewisians, has to come from outside that mosaic if it is to be real. I then outline modal realism and consider objections to the effect that it cannot satisfy these ambitions. This leads into a discussion of david lewis and his claim known as modal realism. On the plurality of worlds phillip bricker the notion of a possible world is familiar from leibnizs philosophy, especially the idea parodied by voltaire in candide that the world we inhabit, the actual world, is the best of all possible worlds. In this chapter, i discuss the view, championed by david lewis, that philosophers talk of possible worlds is the literal truth. According to some possible worlds, 1 is true and 2 false. David lewis possible worlds modal logic space scribd. He certainly is not loathe to take on the controversial issues and their proponents.
Australasian journal of philosophy australasian journal of. Also available online in html, pdf, and epub formats in a sidebyside. I know that phones used to ring, but nowadays squeal, when someone calls up. Among such theorists there is disagreement about the nature of possible worlds. The expressive power of the possible worlds theory in video games. Lewis taught briefly at ucla and then at princeton from 1970 until his death. There are the possible worlds, and they are books of propositions, and one of them is the actual possible. According to lewis modal realism, every possible way that a universe could be is instantiated by one of these possible worlds. What you must do to maintain the reduction of worlds to books is, i think, to declare that the actual world is not a possible world.
The possible worlds of the philosopher, david lewis. He undertakes to isolate the distinguishing traits of conventionality. Possible worlds stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. I believe to have been david kaplan have led me to think again.
David lewis is perhaps best known for taking this notion metaphysically seriously, saying that possible worlds arent just a metaphor but are metaphysically real. In his metaphysical summa of 1986, the plurality of worlds, david lewis famously defends a doctrine he calls modal realism, the idea that to account for the fact that some things are. However, i would recommend ron girles work on possible worlds in preference to dovers, because girle covers much of the same ground in language that a lay person can understand. The concept of possible worlds henceforth pw, loosely inspired by leibniz. Following lewis, this thesis has come to be known by the name humean supervenience, and.
In on the plurality of worlds 1986 lewis set out his modal realism the notion that all possible worlds are actuallyexisting disconnected universes. What does it mean to say something might have been true. The inhabitants of this world are only a few compared to all the inhabitants of all the worlds. Introduction in 1984, peter forrest and david armstrong published an argument against david lewis theory of possible worlds. Diana wynne joness chrestomanciseries and david lewiss theory of fiction 41 4. The thesis states that the world we are part of is but one of a plurality of worlds, as he writes in the preface, and that we who inhabit this world are only a few out of all the inhabitants of all the worlds. Convention i a philosophical study princeton university. That is, one might respond to the possible worlds skeptic not by explaining the metaphor but by taking the story to be the literal truth.
719 1341 581 407 912 899 1543 394 1445 1249 760 1234 1 817 29 836 413 160 875 775 453 1118 554 216 498 409 728 856 1448 1477 44 808 1370